Skip to content
Home » Blog » Buying Dog Supplies Online: What I Order and What I Still Buy in Person

Buying Dog Supplies Online: What I Order and What I Still Buy in Person

Small white dog sitting next to a bowl of dry kibble on a wooden floor

Most of Barnaby’s supplies arrive at my door. Food, poop bags, shampoo and his spare leash all come from online orders, because a 72 lb Golden Retriever goes through the basics fast and I’d rather not haul a 30 lb bag of kibble across a parking lot in Austin heat. A few things I still buy in person, though, and the split is worth thinking through before you set up your own orders.

Start with the food, because it never stops

Food is the one supply you’ll buy forever, so it’s where online ordering saves the most time. The catch is that the bag you click on has to be the right one. Before I order a dog food, I check the label for two things: a named meat near the top of the ingredient list, and an AAFCO nutritional adequacy statement for the right life stage. The FDA explains what that “complete and balanced” statement actually means, and it’s the line I’d look for first.

Here’s what I check before I set up a repeat food order:

  • The life stage on the bag (puppy, adult, or all life stages)
  • An AAFCO statement, not just marketing words like “premium”
  • The bag size I can finish before it goes stale. For one big dog, that’s usually 4 to 6 weeks.
  • Whether the brand has any recent recalls on the FDA recall list

The recall check takes about a minute, and it’s the one people skip.

What I order online, and what I don’t

Some dog supplies are easy to buy blind. Others need a fitting, or at least a look and a squeeze. This is how I split them for Barnaby:

SupplyOnline?WhyMy take
Dry food and treatsYesSame product every timeSet a reminder, not autoship you forget
Poop bags, shampoo, wipesYesBulk is cheaperEasy win
LeashesYes, once you know the typeLength and material are listedI know my 6 ft biothane works
Harnesses and collarsIn person firstFit depends on chest shapeMeasure, then reorder online
BedsEitherSize charts help, feel doesn’tCheck the cover is washable
Chew toysCarefully“Indestructible” means littleBarnaby’s verdict is usually fast

The harness row is the one I’d take seriously. A harness that rubs behind the front legs is worse than no harness, and you can’t feel that through a screen.

Leashes, collars and the stuff that keeps your dog safe

A leash is safety gear first. It keeps your dog out of the road and keeps strangers comfortable when a big dog comes bounding over to say hi. I buy mine online now because I already know what works for Barnaby: a waterproof biothane hands-free leash, 6 ft long. After a wet morning at Walnut Creek Park it rinsed clean in about 10 seconds, and it didn’t get heavy the way my old nylon ones did. In my experience, a soaked nylon leash picks up a fair bit of weight in mud and water.

Collars are different. I’d buy the first one in a store, fit it (two fingers should slide under it), and only then reorder the same size online. GPS and smart collars follow the same rule, plus one more: check the battery life and whether the tracker needs a monthly plan before you buy.

Beds, crates and dog houses

Dog furniture is where online shopping really helps, because a store rarely stocks the big sizes. Barnaby is my bed tester, and he takes it seriously. A few things I look at on any bed listing:

  1. The measured sleeping area, not the outside dimensions
  2. A removable, machine-washable cover
  3. Foam thickness if your dog is big or older
  4. A non-slip base for hard floors

Outdoor dog houses come in single and double-door versions, and some even have two levels. In Texas I’d care less about the design and more about shade, airflow and a raised floor. The ASPCA’s hot weather safety tips are worth reading before you rely on any dog house in summer. A dog house is shelter, not a substitute for bringing a dog inside when it’s dangerously hot.

Grooming supplies and toys

Shampoo, conditioner, brushes and nail clippers are all fine to order online. A Golden who finds water wherever it is means shampoo is on my reorder list for good.

Toys are the tricky category. Barnaby has a reputation on our team for destroying most “indestructible” rubber toys within about 15 minutes, so I read toy listings with a lot of skepticism. Size the toy to your dog’s mouth (big enough that it can’t be swallowed), and take it away once it starts breaking into chunks.

Brown and white dog lying on a living room floor beside a bowl of dog food

How to measure for a harness before you order

My table says to buy the first harness in person, but that isn’t always possible. If you have to order online, measuring properly cuts the odds of a return. You need a soft tape measure and a dog who’ll stand still for about 30 seconds (a treat helps).

Chewy’s short walkthrough below shows the measurements most harness size charts ask for. It’s under two minutes long:

The step I’d add is to measure twice, on different days. A thick coat compresses differently depending on how tightly you pull the tape, and a Golden’s chest fluff can hide an inch.

Write these down before you open any size chart:

  • Chest girth at the widest part, just behind the front legs
  • Neck girth where a collar would sit
  • Current weight
  • The size your dog wears in a brand you already own, if any

If your dog falls between two sizes, many makers suggest sizing up and tightening the straps. Check the brand’s own advice, though, because sizes aren’t standard across companies. A tracker collar needs the same care with fit, and our guide to choosing a GPS dog collar covers that plus battery life.

A first order for a new dog, by priority

When a new dog arrives, it’s tempting to buy everything at once. I’d split the first order into what you need on day one and what can wait until you know the dog. Our guide on helping a new dog settle in covers those first weeks in more detail.

PriorityItemWhy now or why laterMy take
Day oneThe food they already eatAvoids a sudden switchChange gradually later
Day oneCollar, ID tag and leashSafety on the first walkCheck the fit at home
Day oneBowls and an enzyme cleanerMeals and accidentsStainless steel cleans easily
First monthA properly sized bedYou’ll know how they sleepCurlers and sprawlers differ
First monthToysYou’ll learn how they chewStart with two or three
LaterGadgets and extrasOnly if you’ll use themMost can wait

The bed row is the one I’d hold off on longest. Watch whether your dog curls up or sprawls for a week, then read our breakdown of memory foam dog beds before you spend real money.

Food is the exception to “wait and see”. Before you set up a repeat order, spend five minutes with our guide to reading a dog food label, so the bag that keeps arriving is the right one.

How I keep online ordering from getting expensive

Online stores make it easy to compare prices, and coupons do exist. They also make it easy to buy things you don’t need. My rules:

  • Compare the price per pound on food, not the bag price
  • Buy one good harness instead of three cheap ones
  • Skip anything that only promises to make your dog “happier”
  • Keep a short list of what actually ran out this month

That last one has saved me more money than any coupon.

If you’re building a list of the basics for a new dog, our dog care articles cover the rest, from settling in to training. And whatever you order, read the label when it arrives. Products and recipes change, sometimes without much notice.

Jason Hill author badge

About the author

Jason Hill, Head of Product

Jason writes every article on Pets Supplies from Austin, Texas, where he lives with Barnaby, a 4-year-old field-bred Golden Retriever, and Cleo, a 7-year-old torbie cat. A former technical writer turned pet-tech product strategist, he keeps notes on what lasts, what’s easy to clean and what the animals actually use. He isn’t a veterinarian, so every health fact he writes is checked against veterinary sources.

More about Jason and how he researches · Editorial Policy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *